|The Way of Kings|
To begin with, and on a more positive note, The Way of Kings does showcase Sanderson's particular strength as a writer, which is his creativity. Although the fantasy elements of this book are not as surprising and interesting as in Mistborn, mostly because they feel somewhat similar to Mistborn's, but they're interesting nonetheless. Sanderson works hard to establish his world through its culture, geography, and mythologies. His worlds are detailed but not overwhelming. The Way of Kings explores—in a limited way—conflicts between reason and revelation, faith and doubt, myth and history. This is all fine and fun, but the exploration is often times clunky and clumsy.
Now for the not-so-positive. The Way of Kings is riddled with problems. One of Sanderson's biggest weaknesses as a writer is his insistence on explaining just about everything through stunted and uninteresting dialogue. For example, several characters literally spend the majority of the book in a library. The characters, and the readers, are forced to essentially wait around for something to happen. Furthermore, sub-plots and conflicts take hundreds of pages to resolve. And, just like Mistborn, the last few hundred pages is a rush to clear up the many loose-ends Sanderson has created, while still leaving enough mystery to tempt the reader to continue the series. Some twists and turns are genuinely surprising but most are obvious and unfulfilling, even trite. With the extended length of this book and its foreshadowing and preparation, the ending should come as a fist to the gut; it should knock the reader over. The Way of Kings does no such thing. In fact, I rolled my eyes when, after reading over 1200 pages, I read the following: "Most everything was still wrong." If you write a book which is over 1000 pages long, then the landscape of the story better look a whole lot different at the end than it did at the beginning. The Way of Kings, in this regard, is a total misfire—albeit a long one.
Based on the effusive recommendations of others, I had high hopes for The Way of Kings. I wanted to like it. I am a big fan of the Mistborn series, even with its problems. For any one of The Way of Kings' virtues comes multiple storytelling sins. At the end of any good fantasy novel, the reader should feel an insatiable desire to continue the saga, to keep living the adventure. I feel no compulsion to continue The Stormlight Archive, and, therefore, cannot recommend The Way of Kings to other readers.
Other Topics of Interest:
Adaptation, Please: Mistborn
Reflections: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
Ray Bradbury and Me